Make Creative Strategy Less Subjective with the 4 Points Strategy
Creative strategy is usually where logic goes to die in a pile of mood boards and 'brand pillars' that mean absolutely nothing. It’s the part of the deck where someone tries to explain why a specific font 'evokes a sense of community' while everyone else in the room checks their watches. The 4 Points Strategy Framework is the industrial-strength filter designed to stop the 'I feel like' wars. It forces you to anchor every creative decision in a human mess, an uncomfortable truth, and a genuine advantage. If you can’t connect the dots between a real problem and a sharp strategy, you aren't doing strategy - you’re just making expensive art that nobody asked for. This is how you stop being a decorator and start being a strategist.
The TL;DR
Stop letting subjectivity ruin your decks. Use the 4 Points to pin down the human friction (Problem), the secret behavior (Insight), your actual weapon (Advantage), and the singular marching order (Strategy) before the client asks for more 'pop.'
Why This Kills Subjective Nonsense
Most creative strategy fails because it's too polite or too vague. This framework forces you to be honest, which is usually painful but always more effective than 'synergy.'
PROBLEM
Don't give me 'low brand awareness.' That's a spreadsheet problem. What is the friction in the customer's life? Are they confused, cynical, or just exhausted by too many choices? If there's no human tension, your strategy has no teeth.
INSIGHT
This is the Insight. It’s not a percentage; it’s a 'why.' Why do they do the weird things they do? What's the secret belief or behavior that drives their choices? If it doesn't make the client a little uncomfortable, it's probably not an insight.
ADVANTAGE
This is where the lying stops. Is your product actually better, or are you just louder? Your Advantage must be the specific tool that solves the Problem. If your advantage is 'quality,' go back to the drawing board; everyone says that.
STRATEGY
This is the Strategy. It’s the bridge. It connects the Problem, Insight, and Advantage into a single, aggressive sentence. It’s not a tagline; it’s a marching order. If it's more than 15 words, you're still rambling.
PROBLEM
Don't give me 'low brand awareness.' That's a spreadsheet problem. What is the friction in the customer's life? Are they confused, cynical, or just exhausted by too many choices? If there's no human tension, your strategy has no teeth.
INSIGHT
This is the Insight. It’s not a percentage; it’s a 'why.' Why do they do the weird things they do? What's the secret belief or behavior that drives their choices? If it doesn't make the client a little uncomfortable, it's probably not an insight.
ADVANTAGE
This is where the lying stops. Is your product actually better, or are you just louder? Your Advantage must be the specific tool that solves the Problem. If your advantage is 'quality,' go back to the drawing board; everyone says that.
STRATEGY
This is the Strategy. It’s the bridge. It connects the Problem, Insight, and Advantage into a single, aggressive sentence. It’s not a tagline; it’s a marching order. If it's more than 15 words, you're still rambling.
Ways You'll Probably Screw This Up
(And lose the room)
- ×Defining the 'Problem' as a business goal like 'increasing ROI' (narcissistic and boring)
- ×Confusing a 'Fact' with an 'Insight' (Facts describe what is happening; Insights explain why people are weird)
- ×Claiming 'Innovation' is a unique Advantage (it's a buzzword, not a weapon)
- ×Writing a 'Strategy' that is just a list of tactics like 'launch a TikTok challenge'
- ×Ignoring the Insight because it feels 'too negative' for the brand guidelines
- ×Making the Strategy so vague it could apply to a competitor or a different industry entirely
- ×Failing to connect the four points (they aren't four separate ideas, they're a single logical thread)
- ×Trying to solve three problems at once because you're afraid to tell the client 'no'
Strategy is about sacrifice. If you aren't leaving 'good' ideas on the floor to focus on one great one, you aren't doing the work.
Real Examples
Premium Coffee Subscription
Fighting the perception that high-end coffee is only for pretentious snobs.
PROBLEM
People want better coffee but feel intimidated by the 'tasting notes' and gatekeeping of specialty brands.
INSIGHT
They aren't afraid of the flavor; they're afraid of looking stupid in front of a barista or a website.
ADVANTAGE
A 'Taste-First' matching algorithm that uses common food cravings rather than technical jargon.
STRATEGY
Democratize the 'Snob' experience by turning technical expertise into a 'Cheat Code' for the everyday drinker.
PROBLEM
People want better coffee but feel intimidated by the 'tasting notes' and gatekeeping of specialty brands.
INSIGHT
They aren't afraid of the flavor; they're afraid of looking stupid in front of a barista or a website.
ADVANTAGE
A 'Taste-First' matching algorithm that uses common food cravings rather than technical jargon.
STRATEGY
Democratize the 'Snob' experience by turning technical expertise into a 'Cheat Code' for the everyday drinker.
Enterprise Cybersecurity
Breaking through the 'fear-mongering' noise of the security industry.
PROBLEM
IT Directors are paralyzed by 'Alert Fatigue' and the constant noise of 100 different security tools.
INSIGHT
They don't actually fear hackers as much as they fear the 3 AM phone call that ruins their weekend.
ADVANTAGE
A 'Zero-Noise' filtering engine that only triggers for actual, verified threats.
STRATEGY
Position the software as the 'Mute Button' for corporate chaos rather than another 'Shield' for the firewall.
PROBLEM
IT Directors are paralyzed by 'Alert Fatigue' and the constant noise of 100 different security tools.
INSIGHT
They don't actually fear hackers as much as they fear the 3 AM phone call that ruins their weekend.
ADVANTAGE
A 'Zero-Noise' filtering engine that only triggers for actual, verified threats.
STRATEGY
Position the software as the 'Mute Button' for corporate chaos rather than another 'Shield' for the firewall.
Budget Travel App
Competing against giants with massive marketing budgets.
PROBLEM
Travelers spend more time stressing over 'finding the deal' than actually enjoying the vacation.
INSIGHT
The anxiety of 'missing out' on a lower price 10 minutes after booking is more painful than the cost itself.
ADVANTAGE
An automated 'Price Drop' refund policy that pays back the difference even after you've booked.
STRATEGY
Own the 'Post-Purchase Peace' by weaponizing the refund policy as a cure for Buyer's Remorse.
PROBLEM
Travelers spend more time stressing over 'finding the deal' than actually enjoying the vacation.
INSIGHT
The anxiety of 'missing out' on a lower price 10 minutes after booking is more painful than the cost itself.
ADVANTAGE
An automated 'Price Drop' refund policy that pays back the difference even after you've booked.
STRATEGY
Own the 'Post-Purchase Peace' by weaponizing the refund policy as a cure for Buyer's Remorse.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if the client says the 'Problem' sounds too negative?
Tell them that without a problem, there's no reason for their product to exist. Positive-only strategy is just a greeting card, and greeting cards don't sell software.
How do I know if my Advantage is actually an Advantage?
Ask yourself: 'Can my competitor say this with a straight face?' If they can, it's not an advantage. It's just the cost of entry.
Can the 'Strategy' be the tagline?
Usually, no. The Strategy is the internal logic. The tagline is the creative expression of that logic. If you confuse the two, you'll end up with a strategy that's all hat and no cattle.
Is an 'Insight' just a data point from a survey?
Absolutely not. A data point tells you '70% of people are tired.' An insight tells you 'They're tired because they're performing a version of themselves they hate.' Data is the 'what,' Insight is the 'so what.'
What if I have four different strategies for one project?
Then you have zero strategies. Pick the one that has the most teeth and throw the other three in the trash. Strategy is the art of exclusion.
Generate a Framework for your Product Launch Strategy
Use our framework generator to generate various Get Who To By, 4C, 4 Points Strategy, and other frameworks — all in one place and directly to editable Google SLIDES!
Go to Framework Generator