Among awarded campaigns, high performers are 16 times more profitable than low performers
In The Crisis in Creative Effectiveness (2019), Peter Field found creatively awarded campaigns were no more effective than non-awarded ones, but a subset he calls 'high performers' achieve 2x as much pricing power, 5x more market share growth and 16x more profitability than 'low performers'.
More from this source
StatThree in four B2B ads get the lowest possible creative ratingStatPowerful creative exists in B2B but is exceedingly rareStatAt the same extra share of voice, a 5-star ad predicts 3 points of share growth and a 1-star ad noneStatPowerful creative predicts roughly ten times the share growth of mediocre creativeStatTen points of extra share of voice buys about half a point of market share on averageStatFour fifths of a company's value comes from cash flows three or more years awayStatAlmost no marketers measure a campaign beyond six monthsWarningMost B2B budget chases in-market buyers while most buyers are out of the marketPrincipleCreative quality is the only 10-20x sales multiplier marketers still controlPrincipleMeasure four things for every ad: recognition, recall, likeability and clarityPrincipleGreat B2B creative combines Situation, Emotion, Branding and CommitmentPrincipleCreativity and emotion earn attention, build brand-situation links and aid retrieval