PrincipleBrand & Creativity
Measure four things for every ad: recognition, recall, likeability and clarity
The Creative Measurement Checklist asks four questions of every ad. Recognition: what percentage of potential buyers recognise having seen this ad? Recall: what percentage correctly link this ad to the advertiser? Likeability: how do potential buyers score this ad on a scale of 1-5? Clarity: what do they think the key message is? Each should be tracked systematically against your own past ads and competitors' ads.
The evidence
PrincipleFame, Feeling and Fluency - the three things advertising has to produceFluent Devices Case Study - Creativity & Effectiveness: Developing creative best practice for long-term growth in a multi-platform world (System1 Group)PrincipleJudge brand creative on short-term lift in mental availability, not immediate salesTracksuit webinar "Brandformance Formula" with MagicBrief and Eucalyptus+39% / 2x / 2.8xThe most entertaining ads multiply memory, awareness and image liftEntertain or Die 3.0 - Small W•rld x Tracksuit
More from this source
StatThree in four B2B ads get the lowest possible creative ratingStatPowerful creative exists in B2B but is exceedingly rareStatAt the same extra share of voice, a 5-star ad predicts 3 points of share growth and a 1-star ad noneStatPowerful creative predicts roughly ten times the share growth of mediocre creativeStatTen points of extra share of voice buys about half a point of market share on averageStatAmong awarded campaigns, high performers are 16 times more profitable than low performersStatFour fifths of a company's value comes from cash flows three or more years awayStatAlmost no marketers measure a campaign beyond six monthsWarningMost B2B budget chases in-market buyers while most buyers are out of the marketPrincipleCreative quality is the only 10-20x sales multiplier marketers still controlPrincipleGreat B2B creative combines Situation, Emotion, Branding and CommitmentPrincipleCreativity and emotion earn attention, build brand-situation links and aid retrieval