Waitrose & Partners: Sweet Suspicion - A Deliciously Festive Whodunnit
Waitrose & Partners sought to disrupt the predictable landscape of sentimental holiday advertising. They challenged Saatchi & Saatchi London to drive awareness for their premium 'No. 1' range while capturing the attention of a digital-first audience. The goal was to move beyond passive viewing and create a participatory experience that would generate sustained brand momentum and secure early pre-orders for key festive products.
Creative Idea
Turned a festive dessert theft into a national interactive murder mystery starring Matthew Macfadyen.
Waitrose gamified the festive season by launching a multi-week interactive whodunnit that invited the public to solve the theft of a premium dessert, turning a product launch into a high-stakes national conversation through cinematic storytelling.
The Red Velvet Heist That Gamified Christmas
A Masterclass in Suspenseful Media Strategy
Waitrose and Saatchi & Saatchi abandoned the traditional "food-porn" montage for a high-concept mystery that sustained a three-week cultural conversation. To treat the campaign like a prestige drama, MG OMD partnered with ITV to air teasers during high-stakes programming like *Until I Kill You*. The mystery culminated in a reveal during *I’m a Celebrity... Get Me Out of Here!*, ensuring maximum linear reach. This strategy resulted in over 150 million views and a 19% increase in the supermarket’s addressable audience.
Succession Meets the Garden Shed
Directed by BAFTA-winner Lucy Forbes, the production utilized a heavy-hitting ensemble cast to ground the comedy. Matthew Macfadyen channeled his detective repertoire as Detective David, supported by Sian Clifford and Joe Wilkinson. While the public focused on hero products like Brown Butter Mince Pies, the narrative centered on the theft of a No.1 Red Velvet Bauble Dessert. In a clever subversion of the genre, the actual culprit - Steve (Dustin Demri-Burns) - was the least suspected by the public, receiving only 8% of the vote in online polls.
Evidence Boards and Feline Suspects
The campaign extended into the physical world with an interactive "evidence board" at London King’s Cross Station, allowing commuters to analyze clues in person. In-store, Waitrose "Partners" wore t-shirts displaying their own suspect predictions to engage shoppers. Despite the detailed clues pointing toward Steve, the British public remained convinced of a different villain: Fig the Cat topped the official suspect polls with 18% of the vote. The engagement translated to a 4.5% sales growth, outperforming the overall market and attracting 1.5 million new shoppers.
Creative Strategy Deconstructed
Company
A reputation for premium, "crime-worthy" food and a partnership with high-caliber British acting talent.
Category
Competitors rely on sentimental tropes and "food porn" montages that often blend together during the festive season.
Customer
Audiences crave interactive entertainment and "water cooler" moments rather than being passive recipients of traditional advertising.
Culture
The massive popularity of prestige crime dramas and the "whodunnit" genre provided a perfect framework for engagement.
Company
A reputation for premium, "crime-worthy" food and a partnership with high-caliber British acting talent.
Category
Competitors rely on sentimental tropes and "food porn" montages that often blend together during the festive season.
Strategy:
Transform a product launch into a participatory cultural event by gamifying the desire for premium festive food.
Customer
Audiences crave interactive entertainment and "water cooler" moments rather than being passive recipients of traditional advertising.
Culture
The massive popularity of prestige crime dramas and the "whodunnit" genre provided a perfect framework for engagement.
Strategy:
Transform a product launch into a participatory cultural event by gamifying the desire for premium festive food.
Results
The campaign achieved massive scale with 10 million views and 894.2 million impressions. It dominated the cultural conversation, being named the #1 Christmas ad on the YouTube leaderboard. The business impact was significant: the featured Red Velvet Bauble Dessert sold out online, and the campaign drove the biggest trading day in Waitrose history on December 23rd, 2024. It earned extensive media coverage across major outlets like the BBC, ITV, and national newspapers, successfully turning a traditional ad slot into a nationwide interactive event.
894.2M
total impressions
#1
Christmas ad on YouTube leaderboard
Sold Out
Red Velvet Bauble Dessert online
Strategy Technique
Borrow Equity
By leveraging the cultural popularity of prestige crime dramas and casting recognizable TV stars, Waitrose elevated a standard commercial into a must-watch television event.
Explore TechniqueCreative Technique
Detective-story
The campaign adopts the classic tropes of a British murder mystery to transform a retail advertisement into a suspenseful narrative that demands audience participation and sustained attention.
Explore TechniqueCraft Breakdown
The campaign's success lies in its cinematic execution and the strategic use of a multi-part narrative to sustain public interest.
Matthew Macfadyen and an ensemble cast brought prestige TV gravitas to a commercial setting.
Treating the ad like a TV series with teasers and a delayed reveal maximized cultural impact.
The atmospheric, high-end setting made the central dessert feel like a valuable prize worth stealing.
In-store activations and social media polls successfully turned viewers into active investigators.
The blend of high-caliber acting and strategic media scheduling turned a standard commercial into a month-long national event.












