User-generated content and influencer marketing are negatively associated with turning growth into profit
Among campaigns that grew volume, those using user-generated content converted growth into profit 37% of the time against 67% without (about a 30-point penalty, p=0.043). Influencer marketing is almost identical at about -29 points, and across all 217 campaigns it has the deepest negative association with long-term profit of eleven communications strategies (-15 points, p=0.055).
We wrote about this
More from this source
StatHumour is the strongest predictor of whether advertising converts growth into profitStatHumour's profit advantage survives controls and holds across the whole databaseStatHumour pays in serious categories tooPrincipleHumour is a proxy for emotionally charged, broad, memorable work, not a prescriptionPrinciplePositive feeling makes a price feel smallerStatEmotional and rational campaigns grow sales alike, but emotional ones convert it to profit twice as oftenQuote"Rational advertising wins the argument. Emotional advertising earns the right not to have it in the first place."StatHigh executional craft is the second predictor of converting growth into profitStatOn pricing power, craft is a step and only world-class separatesStatA recurring brand character converts growth into profit far more oftenStatA brand character builds pricing power; a celebrity does notStatGrowth is close to a precondition for profit


