What is Creative Ideation? (The Real Answer)

It's not waiting for inspiration to strike. It's not having a "creative brain." It's using proven techniques to generate ideas that work.

Most people think creativity is magic. It's not. The best creative ideas come from systematic thinking—studying what worked before, applying proven techniques, and generating way more options than you think you need. The "magic" happens when you combine different approaches in new ways.

A good creative idea does three things: it solves a real problem (not an imaginary one), it's different from what everyone else is doing (not just slightly different), and it makes people feel something (not just think something). If your idea does all three, you're ahead of 90% of campaigns. Most ideas do zero of these. That's why most campaigns fail.

Why This Actually Matters

Generic Ideas Get Ignored

Your audience sees hundreds of campaigns a day. If your idea looks like everything else, they'll ignore it. Creative ideas stand out. They get noticed. They get remembered. Generic ideas? They get scrolled past. Forever.

Creative Ideas Drive Results

Award-winning campaigns aren't creative for creativity's sake. They're creative AND effective. They drive sales. They build brands. They change behavior. Creative ideas that don't work aren't creative—they're just weird.

You're Competing for Attention

Your competitors are trying to reach the same audience. If your ideas are generic, you're just adding to the noise. Creative ideas cut through. They get attention. They get shared. They get results.

Systematic Beats Random

Waiting for inspiration is a terrible strategy. Using proven techniques is a better one. The best creative teams don't wait for magic—they use systems. They study what worked. They apply techniques. They generate more options. That's how you get better ideas.

100+ Creative Techniques That Actually Work

Here are 100+ creative techniques that real campaigns use. Not theory. Not "best practices" from someone who's never created anything. Actual mechanics with actual examples from award-winning campaigns. Click any technique to see how it works, when to use it, and campaigns that nailed it (or failed spectacularly).

Action movie

Steal the structure of a blockbuster action movie - hero, villain, tension, resolution. Your brand saves the day. It's not original, but it works because everyone already knows the format.

Amplify the Small

Zero in on the most mind-numbingly ordinary detail and shove it in everyone's face until they can't ignore it. Hyper-focus on the thing nobody else bothers with, because apparently, the market is just begging to be told what's important. Nail this, and your brand becomes synonymous with obsessive quality - or at least, obsessive attention to detail.

Analogy

Forget features and benefits - tell them what it *feels* like. Turn your product into a metaphor everyone already understands, even if the competition calls it dumbing down. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Analogy for the Problem

Equate your product to the sweet relief of something universally awful, like untangling headphones or finding a matching sock. Suddenly, you're not selling features, you're selling salvation from the everyday bullshit they already hate. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Analogy for the Solution

Stop trying to explain your revolutionary product with words nobody understands. Just sell them something they already get - "It's like X, but for Y" - and let their brains fill in the blanks because crafting a new analogy is easier than fixing the education system. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Apply Social Pressure

Let everyone else do the selling for you. Show off the crowd already using your product, and watch the holdouts fall in line like dominoes. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Backstage

Pull back the curtain and show how your product actually gets made. The hands, the choices, the reasons why. People are tired of polished bullshit - show them the real thing.

Behind the scenes

Ditch the stock photos and manufactured perfection. Film the chaotic reality of creation - the arguments, the screw-ups, the actual humans behind the machine. Show them the real, and you'll build a connection the competition can only dream of.

Borrow a Familiar Format

Steal a format everyone knows - cooking shows, true crime, reality TV - and fill it with your content. Familiar packaging, unexpected delivery. The contrast does the work.

Break the Norm

Find the dumbest rule everyone in your category blindly follows, then break it on purpose. Not for shock value - because you've got something better to offer.

Break visual expectations

Ditch the stock photos and predictable color palettes the competition vomits up. Violate every visual norm in your category so hard that people stop scrolling and actually pay attention. Do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Celebrate an Attitude

Stop pushing products and start pushing a freakin' ethos. Give people a worldview they can get behind, and make your brand the symbol they rally around. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Celebrate a Symbol

Take the most boring, mundane aspect of your product and imbue it with undeserved significance - the forgotten corner of a website, the crinkling of the packaging, the damn *font*. Do it right, and suddenly you're not selling a product, you're selling a feeling.

Challenge

Set an audacious challenge no one's attempted before and document the whole messy journey. People love watching someone try something stupid-hard. Let them root for you.

Challenge Yourself

Publicly commit to something ballsy, with real consequences if you screw it up. Force yourself to deliver under pressure, while everyone else is playing it safe with their meaningless marketing promises. Do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Challenge your target group

Dare your audience to actually do something. Change a behavior, prove themselves, step up. The ones who take the bait become believers. The rest weren't your people anyway.

Character

Create a fictional character who becomes your brand's voice in everything. Unlike real humans, they won't age, quit, or post something regrettable at 2am.

Collaborate with another brand

Team up with a partner brand willing to share the load – and hopefully, some of the profits. Combine your powers, tap into their audience, and pray the marketing gods favor your unholy union; nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Compare & Contrast

Take your competitor's biggest swing and show everyone how they whiffed it. Line up your product next to theirs and let the audience decide who's phoning it in. Do it right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Comparison

Put two things side by side and let the difference do the talking. Before vs. after, you vs. them, old way vs. new way. Contrast is clarity.

Conduct an Experiment

Put your claims to the test and film the fallout. Rigorous science is a pain in the ass, but proving your product works shuts up the competition for good.

Conduct a Product Trial

Give away the cow to sell the milk - a limited-time product trial. Get them actually *using* the damn thing, not just staring at a login screen, and they'll be addicted before the month is up. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Connect Generations

Bridge the generation gap and watch the olds and the youngs unite over your product - because apparently, shared misery loves company. Find the common ground in a world of TikTok dances and early bird specials, and you'll be the only brand they both agree on.

Consumer contest

Get your audience to create content for you. Sounds lazy, but it works - people trust other people way more than they trust your marketing team.

Crash Someone Else's Party

Find a trending dumpster fire, and throw your product's unique solution on the flames. If you can solve a real problem better than the clowns already trying, you'll steal the spotlight and walk away with their audience.

Create a Ritual

Turn your product into a ritual people want to repeat, not just another transaction. When using your brand feels like tradition, switching becomes unthinkable.

Create Fantasy Worlds, People and Things

Craft a ludicrous alternate reality where your brand's alleged values are the baseline truth, then populate it with characters living the dream. It's pure, unadulterated escapism, but when done right, it's also irresistible - and you'll be the architect of their desires.

Create Urgency

Tell them exactly how long they have to act, and then watch the marketing peasants panic. Set a real deadline, stick to it, and you'll separate the serious buyers from the window shoppers.

Customize and personalize

Give the masses the illusion of choice with a “customization” engine that's really just a few templates and a well-placed color picker. Let them think they're artists while you rake in the profits from their personalized participation trophies. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Cutting-edge Tech

Ditch the tired "disruptive innovation" buzzword bingo and use bleeding-edge tech to solve a problem people actually have. When the tech fades into the background and the user's life gets tangibly better, that's when you're not just playing with gadgets - you're building a brand people can't live without.

Define, Label and Group

Mint a brand new personality type like you're churning out NFTs, slap a catchy label on it, and watch the masses flock to define themselves by your creation. Play it right, and you're not just selling products, you're building a goddamn identity.

Detective-story

Structure your campaign like a mystery - clues, tension, revelation. Your product is the detective who cracks the case. People love solving puzzles; let them solve their way to your brand.

Dramatize the Problem

Stop politely hinting at the problem and start throwing a spotlight on the festering wound your competitors are too scared to acknowledge. Expose the hidden costs, the ignored consequences, the sheer, wasteful idiocy of the status quo until they’re begging for an alternative. Get it right, and you won't just get attention - you'll get loyalty.

Dramatize the Solution

Skip the subtle benefits and go straight for the jugular – before-and-after so stark it's practically an intervention. Make the problem look excruciating, then solve it so completely even your rivals will be taking notes. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Embrace the Weird

Embrace the weird. Expose the strange quirk that marketing teams usually hide, and make it your battle flag because in a sea of same, different wins. Get it right, and you won't just get attention - you'll get loyalty.

Empathize

Dig up your audience's deepest, darkest frustrations and put them on display. Make them relive that excruciating moment of truth before you casually stroll in with the solution they've been praying for. Do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Entertain the crowd

Turn your campaign into a stand-up routine: setup, punchline, then slip in the sales pitch while they're still chuckling. Do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

ESG

Exploit the bleeding hearts of your target audience by pretending to care about something other than profit. Find a trendy cause, throw money at it, and let the actual do-gooders do their thing while you slap your logo on the whole damn operation; do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Exchange Roles

Flip the org chart and let the interns run the show for a day. Expose the cluelessness at the top and the brilliance at the bottom, and watch the whole damn industry re-evaluate its priorities.

Exhibit the Truth

Take something ordinary and exhibit it like precious art. The contrast reframes perception. Trash becomes commentary, habits become statements, the mundane becomes meaningful.

Expose the Hidden

Everyone else is selling smoke and mirrors? Yank the curtain back and show the guts of your operation, the real ingredients, the unflattering process. Let competitors hide their secrets; transparency builds trust and trust gets you paid.

Fairytale

Use fairytale structure - curse, journey, transformation. Your brand is the magic that makes happily-ever-after possible. It sounds cheesy until it works.

Fight prejudice

So, everyone assumes your industry is shady or irrelevant? Perfect. Turn that tired narrative on its head with undeniable proof and stories that actually matter, because shattering those outdated assumptions is way more powerful than any ad campaign. Do it right, and you won't just get attention - you'll get loyalty.

Fight stereotypes

So, everyone thinks you're the boring, expensive, planet-killing option? Good, give them a dose of reality so sharp it cuts through the industry's BS. Do it right, and they’ll realize you're the only honest one in the room.

Fix Tiny Frictions

Find the tiny daily annoyances everyone's accepted as normal, then fix them. Small friction, solved obviously. People will love you for caring about what others ignore.

Gamification

Points, badges, leaderboards — turn your brand into a digital casino and watch those dopamine receptors light up. Exploit the human weakness for shiny things and manufactured status, because the industry already is, so why not you? Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Glorify somebody

Find some random human being who kinda, sorta lives up to your brand's aspirational BS and put them on a pedestal. Make a saint out of someone for doing their job competently, because apparently that's revolutionary these days. Do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Glorify the audience

Forget aspirational bullshit, find the actual damn thing your audience is good at, then make *that* the heart of your brand. Stop selling a lifestyle and start celebrating the hustle, and they'll reward you with something better than likes: loyalty.

Hijack the Medium

Don't just buy media - hijack it. Turn the channel, platform, or format itself into your canvas. When media IS the message, people can't scroll past.

Honesty

Spill the beans on your product's biggest flaw – the internet already knows, and your competitors' sugarcoating is pathetic. Turn that weakness into a badge of honor by admitting what everyone else is too afraid to say, because in this sea of marketing lies, brutal honesty cuts through the noise. Do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Horror movie

Frame the problem your product solves as the monster in a horror film. Build dread, show the threat, then deliver the relief. Fear sells when used responsibly.

Install it

Build a pointless monument to your brand that serves no purpose except to remind people you exist. Offer a fleeting moment of genuine value, then ambush them with branding on the way out because subtlety is dead, baby. Do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Invent a Complementary Product

So, you've got a product... now invent the problem it solves even better. Create a whole ecosystem of accessories and add-ons that are inexplicably "essential" - the competition will be stuck selling one thing while you're selling a lifestyle. Do it right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Label

Coin a term people will actually use to describe themselves or their problem. A sticky label spreads on its own. Just make sure it can't be weaponized against you.

Lean Into the Problem

Everyone else is pretending their category is perfect, so highlight the gaping hole your product fills. Lean into the problem, show how ugly it is, and then position your brand as the only damn solution. Do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Lovestory

Tell a love story where your product enables deeper connection. Not cheesy romance - real tension, real effort, real payoff. Hallmark is not the goal.

Make an Enemy

Find the 800-pound gorilla in your industry and publicly body-slam it through a table. Position yourself as the only alternative to the soul-crushing status quo, and you'll win over the people who are sick of their crap.

Make a Parody

Mock the conventions everyone's tired of - competitors, category clichés, cultural BS. Exaggerate until the absurdity is undeniable. Humor lands harder than lectures.

Make em feel Guilty

Hit 'em where it hurts: Show the consequences of their apathy, then offer your product as the only ethical way out of this mess. Guilt is a powerful motivator, and conveniently, you're the solution to the problem they never knew they had. Get it right, and you won't just get attention - you'll get loyalty.

Make it nostalgic

Dig up a dead trend and give it CPR with your brand's logo. Everyone's a sucker for the past - weaponize that longing and you'll be swimming in their sentimental cash.

New problems

Yeah, your amazing solution has drawbacks – shocker. Acknowledge the problems you create, then solve those too, because transparency is the new black, and owning your downsides is the only way to build trust that actually lasts.

Path is more than destination

Forget the victory lap; film the stumble, the sweat, and the existential dread. If the competition is selling flawless success, sell the messy, human truth they're too scared to show, and you'll be the only brand that feels real.

Play a mediator

Everyone's fighting, so swoop in and be the reasonable adult in the room, even if it's just an act. Don't solve the problem, just sell shovels to both sides of the culture war, and you'll be the only one getting rich.

Prank

Fake 'em out with a ridiculous stunt, then drop some actual wisdom when they're least expecting it. The industry's full of predictable garbage, so shock them into paying attention, and you'll be the only ones they remember.

Push It to the Limit

Push your product to its absolute limits and document what happens. If it survives genuine punishment, you've got proof that beats any claim. If it fails, well... better you find out first.

Question Everything

Forget selling features; dissect every sacred cow in your category until customers realize they've been royally screwed by the competition. Ask the questions nobody else dares to, and you’ll be the only sane option left standing.

Rare product

Create artificial scarcity and own it. Limited drops, exclusive access, manufactured FOMO. It's manipulative, everyone knows it, and it still works every damn time.

Real-Time Relevance

Link your brand to real-world triggers - weather, time, events, location. When context changes, your message adapts. It's not creepy, it's just relevance done right.

Retell a Known Story

Take a story everyone knows and tell it from a new angle - the forgotten perspective, the untold side, the what-if. Familiar stories retold hit different.

Reverse Expectations

Do the exact opposite of what your category always does. When everyone zigs, zag hard. Surprise is memorable; predictability is invisible.

Screw It Up Intentionally

Intentionally screw up your own launch - promise the moon and deliver a rock. If the fallout is more compelling than the product ever could be, you've created a narrative that burns itself into the collective consciousness.

Show, Don't Tell

Show, don't tell. Demonstrate what happens without your product versus with it. Make the transformation so obvious that explaining becomes unnecessary.

Show the Future

Don't just hawk features, sell the goddamn future where everyone's already using your product and wondering how they lived without it. Skip the vague promises and paint a picture so real, it feels like a leaked preview from next Tuesday. Get this right, and you're not just selling a product, you're selling inevitability.

Simplicity

Strip away the useless features and marketing jargon until only the core value remains. If your competitors need 100 words to say nothing, you say everything with one. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Sing a song

Write a jingle so catchy it makes people actively hate you - then realize they can't stop humming it. When everyone else is fighting for awards, you'll be stuck in their heads, rent-free, and you'll be the only one they remember.

Spacetime Warp

Rip something out of its time and slam it into ours, or vice versa – caveman lawyers, robot gladiators, whatever. Watch the gears grind as old meets new and exposes the ridiculousness of "progress"… or just gets you some eyeballs. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Spotlight the Overlooked

Spot the overlooked thing that actually matters to your people, then throw a spotlight on it. Make the invisible feel seen. That's how you earn loyalty.

Story-Driven Campaign

Tell a story with real tension, real stakes, real resolution. Your product is the tool, not the hero. Nobody cares about your brand - they care about the story.

Support the underdogs

Find some scrappy underdogs fighting the good fight and toss them a bone (publicly, of course). Let them be the David to your Goliath-adjacent brand, and watch the halo effect work its magic. Do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Take a Real Stand

Pick a cause worth fighting for and actually fight for it. Not a logo on a pride float - real resources, real risk, real action. People join fights, not statements.

Take a Shot at the Competition

Name names. Put your product next to theirs under identical conditions. Let real people decide while cameras roll. If you win, you've got proof. If you lose, well... maybe don't post that one.

Technology

Use tech that actually solves a problem - AR, apps, live features, whatever. Not tech for tech's sake, but tech that makes the experience better. Gimmicks die fast; useful tools stick.

Tell a story: Against all odds

Craft a narrative where your brand isn't just present, but the silent partner in an underdog's improbable triumph over some rigged system. Do it right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Tell a story: Against social norms

Find the dumbest social convention in your category, then gleefully burn it to the ground. When you give the silent majority permission to break the rules, you don't just get customers - you get a goddamn army.

Tell a story: Conflict

Exploit the oldest trick in the book - good old-fashioned conflict. Two opposing forces, clashing needs, a ticking clock - skip the fake kumbaya bullshit and show the raw, messy struggle everyone actually deals with. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Tell a story: Internal conflict

Expose the inner turmoil, the compromises, the crap choices people secretly battle. Position your brand as the weapon they need to finally win the war against themselves - and build a following of ride-or-die loyalists in the process.

Testimonial

Let your customers do the talking - after all, they're the only ones anyone believes anyway. Find the most brutally honest, warts-and-all endorsements you can, because nobody trusts a perfectly polished lie from a soulless corporation. Do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Tribe Builder

Give your audience an identity they actually want. Not 'customer' - something with purpose, missions, and bragging rights. People don't buy products, they join tribes.

Turn Failure into Success

Own your failures loudly. Show the 5,000 prototypes that sucked before this one worked. Failure stories humanize brands and make success feel earned, not lucky.

Turn Message into Product

Turn your brand message into an actual product people can use or keep. Tangible beats talk. Plus, a weird product from an unexpected brand is basically free PR.

Unexpected audio

Screw the focus-grouped elevator music and hit them with audio they won't see coming. Static, whale song, dial-up modem screech - anything to shatter the predictable ad soundtrack. Do it right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Unexpected environment

Stick your ads where they least belong – graveyards, dumpsters, congressional hearings. Force people to notice you by violating the bland expectations of the category. Do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Unexpected Utility

Take existing crap and force it to do something useful for a change. Repurpose the mundane into the unexpected, and you might just trick people into paying attention.

Unspoken Conflict

Find the tension your audience feels but can't articulate - values vs. desires, self vs. society. Name the conflict, and you own the conversation.

Use a famous song

Borrow a song people already love and let it carry your story. The emotional heavy lifting is already done - you just need to aim it right. Licensing costs hurt; results don't lie.

Use Another Category's cliché

Rip off another category's most overused cliché and make it your own. Everyone's tired of the same old song and dance, so borrowing someone else's might just be crazy enough to work; do this right, and nobody forgets your brand.

Use Art

Find an artist willing to whore themselves out for your brand, then call it a "collaboration." It's still a commercial transaction, but now it's got a fancy frame and a velvet rope. Nail this, and your campaign becomes the one everyone talks about.

Use Different Language

Take your message and express it in a completely different language - music, code, art, dance. Same meaning, different medium. Translation reveals what explanation hides.

Use the Power of Cute

Deploy cuteness strategically - mascots, animations, characters that make people go 'aww.' Cute bypasses rational filters and lands straight in the heart. Just don't overdo it.

Wordplays

Embrace the groan. Squeeze every last drop of wit from language, even if it lands squarely in Dad Joke territory, because in a world of forgettable noise, the memorable often wins. Execute with precision, and your brand's name becomes synonymous with 'unforgettable.'

Stop brainstorming and start generating. Our creative session tool uses these 100+ techniques to give you actual campaign ideas, not more blank pages to stare at.

Generate Ideas Now →

How to Actually Generate Creative Ideas (Step-by-Step)

Know Your Brand and Audience (Actually Know Them)

Before you generate anything, know what you stand for and who you're talking to. What's your brand's purpose? What does your audience care about? What problems do they have? If you don't know this, your ideas will miss. Every time. Don't guess. Research. Ask them. Know them better than they know themselves.

Study What Worked Before

Look at award-winning campaigns in your category. See what mechanics they used. What made them work? Don't copy—learn. Understand the patterns. Then apply those patterns to your brand. Most people skip this step and wonder why their ideas are generic. Don't be most people.

Use Proven Creative Techniques

Don't just wing it. Look at the 100+ techniques above. Gamification, social proof, extreme challenges, visual metaphors—each one works for different situations. Match the technique to your message, not your mood. Each technique has specific strengths. Use the right one.

Generate Way More Options Than You Think

50-100 ideas minimum. Not 5. Not 10. Quantity beats quality in ideation because your first ideas are usually terrible. Generate a ton, then filter. Use our tool, brainstorm, whatever—just make more options than you think you need. The best idea is rarely the first one you think of.

Test and Refine

Test your ideas with your audience. See what resonates. What makes them feel something? What do they remember? Refine based on feedback. Most people fall in love with their first idea and skip testing. Don't do that. The idea that works isn't always the one you love most.

Mistakes That Kill Your Creative Ideas

Waiting for inspiration instead of using techniques

Inspiration is unreliable. Techniques are reliable. The best creative teams don't wait for magic—they use systems. They study what worked. They apply techniques. They generate more options. Stop waiting. Start using.

Generating 5 ideas and calling it done

Your first ideas are usually terrible. That's normal. The problem is stopping there. Generate 50-100 ideas. Then filter. Quantity beats quality in ideation. Most people generate 5 ideas and wonder why they're all generic. Generate more.

Not studying what worked before

Award-winning campaigns exist for a reason. They worked. Study them. See what mechanics they used. Understand why they worked. Then apply those patterns to your brand. Most people skip this and wonder why their ideas are generic.

Being creative for creativity's sake

Creative ideas that don't work aren't creative—they're just weird. Good ideas are creative AND effective. They solve problems. They drive results. They make people feel something. If your idea is just creative without being effective, it's not a good idea.

Not testing your ideas

Most people fall in love with their first idea and skip testing. That's why most campaigns fail. Test your ideas. See what resonates. What makes people feel something? What do they remember? Refine based on feedback. Don't skip this step.

Questions People Actually Ask

How do you come up with creative ideas?

Stop waiting for inspiration. Use proven techniques. Study what worked before. Apply creative mechanics from award-winning campaigns. Combine different approaches. Generate way more options than you think you need. The best ideas come from systematic thinking, not magic moments. We've got 100+ techniques that actually work—use them.

What makes a creative idea good?

It solves a real problem. It's different from what everyone else is doing. People remember it. It makes them feel something. And it actually works—not just in theory, but in the real world. Most "creative" ideas fail because they're creative for creativity's sake. Good ideas are creative AND effective. Both matter.

How do you brainstorm creative campaign ideas?

Don't just sit in a room and hope. Use proven techniques. Study award-winning campaigns. Apply creative mechanics. Generate 50-100 ideas, not 5. Don't filter too early. Test them. See what actually works. Most brainstorming sessions are just people saying the same things they always say. Break the pattern. Use the techniques that work.

What are creative techniques in marketing?

Creative techniques are proven methods for generating campaign ideas. They're not theory—they're actual mechanics used by award-winning campaigns. Gamification, social proof, extreme challenges, visual metaphors, storytelling frameworks—we've got 100+ techniques above. Each one works for different situations. Use the right one for your brand.

How do you generate creative ideas for campaigns?

Start with your brand and audience. Know what you stand for. Then use proven creative techniques—we've got 100+ above. Study what worked before. Apply different mechanics. Generate way more options than you need. Test them. The process isn't magic—it's systematic. Most people skip the systematic part and wonder why their ideas are generic.

Ready to Generate Better Ideas?

Generate actual campaign ideas using 100+ proven techniques. No more "brainstorming sessions" that go nowhere.